Comments Locked

19 Comments

Back to Article

  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 22, 2003 - link

    the P4 2.4GHz 800MHz you have listed on NewEgg for $175 is the OEM version. All of the other chips you link to NewEgg are the retail versions. Was that a mistake on the part of Anandtech or did NewEgg change their prices? I was considering purchasing it, but to pay an extra ~$10 for the retail.. if that's the case I might be willing to pay an extra ~$10 on top of that to get the 2.6 from somewhere else. Is it possible for me to get NewEgg to give me the retail 2.4 for $175 or do you think I should give up on that idea? Any advice would be appreciated. jeff_lin@hotmail.com
  • MadAd - Thursday, October 16, 2003 - link

    (also posted in the comments following the current price guides article)

    Ive just had an idea looking at your ram tables - hopefully others will find it useful too.

    I would guess 'most of us' arent really interested in the exact price of say, 2700 or 3200 unless we are actually making a purchase in the immediate future. However in the same vein, that same 'most of us' would probably like to keep abreast of the average pricing at any given time.


    Keep the same page as you have now (the micro information will suit immediate intended purchasers) but also add a shortlist table at the bottom. This would be a round up, at-a-glance averages table composed of each ram category and a figure next to it representing the average price of a stick in that category.

    EG, using this months figures (price column based)
    2700/256 - $45.66
    2700/512 - $83.90
    3200 etc etc
    etc

    (2700/256 figures composed of ($) 44 + 45 + 42 + 55 + 45 + 43 / 6 = 45.66).

    With a bit of further thought, as well as avg price, maybe a top bottom and average table for each group? Dunno - its up to you, however the average price in any given month would be a good guide to skim imo, and it wouldnt need a scientist to link the data from the current prices, so creating an autofilling table.

    Ad

    (also mailed to Kris)
  • KF - Wednesday, October 15, 2003 - link

    Since we are getting into future prediction, I predict prices on lower speed grade CPUs are going up. Don't wait 6 weeks in the hope that you can save $5. Why? The economy is picking up according to almost all statistics by now. As people get into the swing of buying again, demand for economy CPUs, which represent the best value, is going up. At the sub $100 level, I think anyone would agree CPU prices have been depressed.

    As for the holiday season bringing lower prices, that's not the way I remember it. Yes there are specials around that time, but if you have a memory for prices, those list prices from which they are marked down carry a holiday season inflation, and even if it is a good price, you often can't get the specials because they sell out so fast. The specials before the holiday season are generally better. Most holiday seasons, I end up sitting on the sidelines in buying for my personal use.

    I think what the memory manufacturers have done is to anticipate the upswing a little to much, which has produced an oversupply.

    Of course, my crystal ball is not any clearer than anyone else's
  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 15, 2003 - link

    I really dont forsee their prices coming down anytime soon. The memory manufacturers made a mistake in cutting the prices so low to begin with. There isnt much of a premium on PC3200, so I would buy now.

    Kristopher
  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 15, 2003 - link

    #12 - IronChefMorimoto here. I'm running the board at 333MHz. No intentions of overclocking (very little if I decide to anyway). I just want at least 1GB of memory at a slightly higher speed. PC2700 or PC3200 -- which one to buy, right now, and will either come down in price anytime soon? The prices have just been so high and stagnant of late.

    IronChefMorimoto
  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 15, 2003 - link

    #12 in your case are you actually running the motherboard at 400MHz FSB? I wouldnt see anything wrong with Corsair PC3200 in either case.

    Kristopher
  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 15, 2003 - link

    I am not sure how "If you’re building a budget system for mom, the Celeron line is looking pretty attractive. Those 2.6GHz chips that debuted about 3 months ago are hovering between $85 and $90." became buy a celeron instead of a barton.

    I pulled that comment anyway. I sill do not recommend buying AMD systems for at least 6 weeks (that doesnt mean buy Intel ones instead). Athlon 64's launch will continue to pump prices for a few weeks to come, and only then in time for the holiday season will we see cuts in the XP line.

    Kristopher
  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 15, 2003 - link

    Here's my question -- when WILL the price of memory drop? It was really hard to get a general statement on the price of X and Y speed memory from the article. Can the author just recommend a good memory buy right now at all?

    I've been sitting on an nForce2 400MHz motherboard + AMD AthlonXP 2500+ for 2 months now -- running old Crucial PC2100 memory (512MB) and waiting for prices to come down.

    IronChefMorimoto
  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 15, 2003 - link

    I hate to contribute on this but seriously.

    AthlonXP 2500+ $85
    Celeron 2.6ghz $85

    Even Intel Fanboys would take the athlon. What are you recommending celerons for? LOL
  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 15, 2003 - link

    #9 is right. The new A64 boards have been reported to be rock solid. So what is the problem?
    Also, it doesnt matter if AMD prices are on the rise. Anandtech is a respectable site but when you guys start saying check out a celeron instead of a barton, you guys lose my respect.
  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 15, 2003 - link

    #8 I can understand if people are cautious about early motherboards, but I find people using the Athlon 64 core as their sole excuse not to purchase just naive.

    Since the basic core of the Athlon 64 has been on the market for over 6 months in the form of the Opteron I have to ask how old should this "1st generation processor" be before it can be safely recommended?
  • Anonymous User - Tuesday, October 14, 2003 - link

    As for spending 400 bucks on a 1st generation processor, I could never recommend that. I would never recommend the 3.2GHz P4 either!

    Kristopher
  • Anonymous User - Tuesday, October 14, 2003 - link

    The main reason I did not recommend an AMD system over an Intel system this time is because AMD prices are on the rise. I personally would have bought a 2500+ myself, but it is my opinion to wait a couple weeks for the prices to stabilize.

    Kristopher
  • Anonymous User - Tuesday, October 14, 2003 - link

    #3 recommending a 2.4 GHz P4 at more than twice the price of a AXP 2500+ as a "bargain" stinks also - how comes? Aces used to be a reliable source, but i do not get their reasoning this time.
  • Anonymous User - Tuesday, October 14, 2003 - link

    2.6c has a $30.50 premium over the 2.4c, not a $20 one.
  • Anonymous User - Tuesday, October 14, 2003 - link

    #3 I second that. Now is a great time to build an amd system. The athlon 64 for $404 that is a great price the 3.2ghz p4 is $600 and that's only 32bits. The reviewer dropped the ball here.
  • Anonymous User - Tuesday, October 14, 2003 - link

    they say it's not a good time to build an amd system on the first page when you can get the barton 2500+ for $85 which is an awesome overclocker and awesome processor in general....then they say the celeron line is looking attractive with a 2.6ghz celeron at $85-90....is it just me or is that a load of crap....who would buy a celeron over a 2500+ barton? Somewhere I missed the logic
  • Anonymous User - Tuesday, October 14, 2003 - link

    Hi, just want to let you know that the word "effected" on the front page should be "affected" instead. No biggie, just a common mistake!
  • Anonymous User - Tuesday, October 14, 2003 - link

    would it be possible to put a price per megabyte column for the ram?

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now