PC Power & Cooling Silencer 500W
by Christoph Katzer on June 9, 2008 2:00 AM EST- Posted in
- Cases/Cooling/PSUs
Fan Speed
The fan starts rotating at 1240 RPM, which is already somewhat high. It would be perfectly acceptable to keep the fan at this speed until higher loads, since the power supply doesn't really get much warmer inside until higher loads. However, as the graphs show the fan starts turning faster with every single step of load we applied. The maximum 3200 RPM is reached quite fast at only 80% of load, which is clearly not necessary. PCP&C continues to ascribe to the "better safe than sorry" approach to PSU cooling - not a bad idea, but also not necessary at some point.
Acoustics
The acoustics table shows it clearly that there is a heavy increase in acoustic noise during operation. We could live with the 20dB(A) reached at a medium load of 250W, but 35dB(A) with just a little more than 350W more isn't something we would be happy with. To put things in perspective, we've tested other power supplies that deliver over 1000W of power without reaching such a high noise level. We're not at all convinced by the "Silencer" name in this case.
22 Comments
View All Comments
xeizo - Monday, June 9, 2008 - link
I´m also positive to the importance of reporting ripple figures, the standard is max.50mV ripple but lately there is a lot of psus sold happily stating 150mV ripple in their specs even though it´s out of the standard.If such companies voluntarily reports 150mV one can only guess how high the real figures are. Or how many more companies out there are a little bit smarter and state 50mV ripple even though the real figures are mabe ~200mV.
High ripple can damage many parts in the computer, lowers performance and rises temperature. So, yes, it's pretty important and should be mentioned in all psu reviews. Not mentioning it is no guarantee that the performance is really great.
HOOfan 1 - Monday, June 9, 2008 - link
50mV is the max specification on the 3.3V and 5V rails. The max spec on the 12V rails is 120mV.