3-Way Low Profile CPU Cooling Shoot-Out: Reeven, Phanteks, & Noctuaby E. Fylladitakis on January 18, 2017 8:00 AM EST
- Posted in
A good CPU cooler can usually be found at the top spots of an enthusiast’s shopping list, as stock coolers rarely are sufficient for the wants and needs of advanced users, especially when overclocking is involved. Choosing the right aftermarket product can be a little complicated, mostly depending on what the product’s focus is and the available budget. For example, some products have been designed to be as quiet as possible while others strictly aim for maximum thermal performance and neglect acoustic comfort completely. Even if two coolers cost about the same, their behavior can be radically different, and it falls to the user to make a judicious choice according to his/her needs.
Whether the focus of the user is quieter operation or higher thermal performance, there is another factor that can make the purchase of a good cooler complicated: size. Sometimes you cannot just buy the best cooler for the job for the simple reason that it will not fit into the system. This is particularly true for compact and/or narrow cases, especially those meant for ITX systems and horizontal placement. With the majority of typical CPU coolers being tower-type constructs, it is difficult to find one that fits inside compact case designs.
To combat this, many manufacturers designed and produced horizontal coolers, i.e. coolers with the fin array placed horizontally instead of vertically. Horizontal coolers are much shorter than typical tower coolers and tend to cool the motherboard’s parts better as well, yet rumor has it that they do not perform as well as tower coolers. The truth is that size/mass is a major factor here as well, meaning that the horizontal designs are meant to be compact and usually just lack the mass of comparable tower cooler designs.
In today's review we will explore three such lower-profile coolers; the Reeven Steropes RC-1206b, the Phanteks PH-TC12LS and the Noctua NH-C14S. These horizontal coolers are all meant for desktop/HTPC designs but they also are significantly different in terms of size, with the Steropes starting at 60 mm tall, moving up to 74 mm with the PH-TC12LS and jumping up to 115/142 mm with the NH-C14S. In the following pages we will explore their design, quality and performance.
|Horizontal GPU Cooler Roundup|
|Reeven Steropes RC-1206b||Phanteks PH-TC12LS||Noctua NH-C14S|
|Fan(s) (mm)||120 (low profile)||120||140|
|Fan Speed (RPM)||2000||1800||1500|
|Current Retail Price||$40||$40||$75|
Post Your CommentPlease log in or sign up to comment.
View All Comments
Yuriman - Tuesday, January 24, 2017 - linkSeems to me a review like this would be a lot more useful if heatsinks were normalized for a specific temperature or noise level. E.g. "The Cryorig produces 40dba keeping our 60w test load at 60c, and 35dba keeping it at 80c", or perhaps "At 35dba, the Noctua cooler kept our test load at 53c. With the Coolermaster cooler, due to the poor quality of the fan we were unable to get a sound pressure reading of 35dba without stopping the fan."
pseudoid - Tuesday, February 28, 2017 - linkJanuary 2016, I built a work-horse PC around the i7-6700K + Asus Z170 Deluxe Motherboard, inside of a 3U (5.75" Height) RackMount Chassis and the Noctua NH-C14S (single fan) was about the max height w/o going water cooling route. I run the 6700K @20% OC (4.8GHz) reliably, all the while the Asus MoBo LEDs never getting into the RED range. Noctua fans are warranted for 6years, which made my purchase a no-brainer.
Antoine. - Tuesday, January 23, 2018 - linkFYI, the C14S perfectly fits in a Streacom F12C case (even with the fan on top)! I know, I have both and tested both options when I was setting it up!